GUAM AND THE SCO: A COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS

Konstantin SYROEZHKIN


Konstantin Syroezhkin, D.Sc. (Political Science), professor, chief fellow at the Institute of Strategic Studies of Kazakhstan under the President of the Republic of Kazakhstan (Almaty, Kazakhstan)


Numerous organizations have been born and died on the post-Soviet expanse; the larger part of them left no trace and therefore can be safely forgotten. Two organizations, however, deserve our special attention. I have in mind the Organization for Democracy and Economic DevelopmentGUAM and the Shanghai Cooperation Organization, not so much because they are rivals of sorts, but because the way they were formed and developed, their response to events, and many other things are similar. Any attempt to compare two international organizations is a thankless task, however, I shall undertake it here.

The Outside Players

The SCO and GUAM are not mere rivalseach of them is supported by outside players with great geopolitical ambitions. GUAM is backed by the United States joined recently by the European Union; the SCO has China behind it, which has great designs for the post-Soviet expanse. This accounts for their specifics and their attitudes toward Russia, which claims the role of key player on the post-Soviet expanse.

Proof of the above is easily found in the two structures history, which reveals not merely the reasons for their emergence, but also the interests of the outside players involved.

The SCOs status is clear enough: China is obviously interested in it and is working hard to channel it in the desirable direction. Sometimes it succeeds, sometimes it fails, because so far it is treading cautiously so as not to irritate Russia. In short, it has to bear in mind Russias interests and ambitions. The expert community, however, agrees that the SCO was set up on Chinas initiative, which needed a lever of influence in Central Asia.

The Agreement on Confidence-Building Measures in the Military Sphere in Border Areas signed in April 1996 in Shanghai and its component, the Agreement on Mutual Reduction of Armed Forces in the Border Area signed in Moscow in April 1997, laid the foundation of the Shanghai Five; in the late 1990s it was transformed into the Shanghai Forum, which in June 2001 became the Shanghai Cooperation Organization.

From the very beginning, that is, from the mid-1990s, China regarded the new structure as a vehicle of


Please fill subscription form to obtain full text of this jounal

SCImago Journal & Country Rank
UP - E-MAIL